Comparative Analysis of OLSR and DSR Routing Protocol Performance on Vehicular Ad Hoc Network (VANET)

Ery Safrianti
Linna Oktaviana Sari
Ahmad Romadan
Feranita Feranita

Abstract


Communication between vehicles is essential in increasing comfort and safety for drivers and passengers. Technology advancements offer a new concept: the Vehicular Ad Hoc Network (VANET). The VANET network allows vehicles on the road to communicate directly with other vehicles while moving and without using the fixed infrastructure. A routing protocol is needed to facilitate communication in the network. Routing protocols are used to find routes between nodes to send messages to each other and forward packets along the selected route. In this study, a comparative analysis of the performance of the topology-based routing protocols will be carried out: Optimized Link State Routing (OLSR) and Dynamic Source Routing (DSR) on VANET with a case study of urban road scenarios. Both protocols are simulated using Network Simulator 2 (NS-2) with a scenario of changing the number of nodes. The two protocols were compared and analyzed from the parameters of packet delivery ratio, end-to-end delay, routing overhead, throughput, packet loss, and collision rate. Based on the simulation results, the overall DSR routing protocol has a better performance value with an average Packet delivery ratio of 99.92%, End-to-end delay of 0.0894 ms, Routing overhead of 1,000 ms, the throughput of 261.55 kbps, Packet loss of 0.0778% and collision rate 1.8770. While the OLSR routing protocol has an average value of Packet delivery ratio of 99.89%, End-to-end delay of 0.0878 ms, Routing overhead of 1,000 ms, throughput of 230.27 kbps, Packet loss of 0.1007%, and collision rate of 1.6687.


Keywords


DSR; OLSR; Routing Protocol; QoS; VANET

Teks Lengkap:

PDF

Referensi


[1] Hilman, A., A. Suharyadi, S. Rachman and I. Akbar. 2018. Analysis of Aodv And Dsdv Protocol Performance On The Vanet Network. Faculty of electrical engineering. Mataram University.

[2] Anisia, R.R. Munadi, and R.M. Country. 2016. Analysis of Olsr And Aomdv Routing Protocol Performance on Vehicular Ad Hoc Network (Vanet). National Journal of Electrical Engineering, 5(1):87–97.

[3] Luthfan, O.Z., R. Munadi and T. Adiprabowo. 2016. Analysis of Hybrid Topology Simulation on Wireless Sensor Network Using Routing Protocol Optimized Link State Routing and Dynamic Source Routing. E-Proceeding of Engineering, 3(3):4477-4488.

[4] Hadiwiriyanto, R., P.H. Trisnawan and K. Amron. 2018. Implementation of the Geographic Source Routing (GSR) Protocol on the Vehicular Ad-Hoc Network (VANET) for Vehicle Communications With Road Side Units (RSU). Journal of Information Technology Development and Computer Science, 2(12):7007-7016.

[5] Nur, A.R. 2016. Vehicular Ad-Hoc Network (Vanet): An Overview Of The Architecture, Characteristics, Applications, And Protocols Of Medium Access Control (Mac). LIGHTNING Journal, 9(1):28-37.

[6] Faikah, A., R. Munadi and L.V. Yovita. 2014. Analysis of Routing Performance of Gpsr, Gytar, and B-Mfr Protocols on Vanets for Inter Vehicle Communication. e-Proceeding of Engineering. 1(1):127-137. [7] Nurlita, D.I., R. Munadi and L.Y. Vidya. 2016. Simulation and Performance Analysis of Gprs and Gytar Position-Based Routing Protocols for Vehicle Communication On the Vehicular Ad Hoc Network (Vanet). Faculty of Electrical Engineering. Telkom University. 23-31.eit

[8] Tri, W.A.M.D., R. Munadi and R. Mayasari. 2018. Analysis of the Effect of Dynamic Source Routing and Temporally Ordered Routing Algorithm on Data Collisions on Vanets. Telecommunications engineering. Telkom University. 20(4):138-144.

[9] Irfan, D.M., D. Perdana and R.M. Country. 2016. Comparative Analysis of DSDV and OLSR Routing Protocol Performance for Changes in Mobility Speed on the IEEE 802.11ah Standard. Infotel Journal, 8(2):100-106.

[10] Angelia, T.A., H.K. Wardana and S. Nugroho. 2015. Simulation and Performance Assessment of Vehicular Ad Hoc Network. Techné Scientific Journal of Electrotechnics, 14(1):27-34.

[11] Kamarullah, K., Endroyono and Wirawan. 2017. Cross-Layer Optimization for Dynamic Source Routing Protocols in Vehicle Inter-Vehicle Communication Based on Vehicular Ad-Hoc Networks (VANETs). Journal of ITS Engineering, 6(2):443-448.

[12] Haredi, H. 2018. Comparative Analysis of AODV and DSR Routing Protocol Performance Against Black Hole Attacks on MANET Networks. Final thesis. Industrial Technology Faculty. Indonesian Islamic University. Yogyakarta




DOI: https://doi.org/10.24176/simet.v14i2.9875

Article Metrics

Abstract views : 64| PDF views : 49

Refbacks

  • Saat ini tidak ada refbacks.


free hit counter View My Stats

Indexed by:

Dimensions logo

 

Flag Counter

Creative Commons License
Simetris : Jurnal Teknik Mesin, Elektro dan Ilmu Komputer is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Dedicated to: